Home > Products > FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions
 


Home

Products
     Overview
     Aspect-Prospect
     NEO
     Mac Products
     Wafian HR1
     Tech Notes
     FAQ

Technology
     Overview
     Quality Analysis
     Learn More

Film Workflow

Support

Press
     Press Releases
     Reviews
     Awards
     Events
     Press Tools

Customer Showcase

About CineForm
     Background
     Management
     Careers

Purchase
     Online Store
     Resellers
     Partner Systems

 

Frequently Asked Questions

Some information about where to get questions answered and technical support....

FAQ: General Q&A about CineForm products and workflow. 

Tech Notes: Detailed descriptions about selected special topics and workflow items.

Technical Support: If you have general technical support questions, please visit our technical support site or else email support@cineform.com.

Forums: CineForm's CTO David Newman is very active on two forum sites, dvinfo.net and dvxuser.com, at which there are active CineForm discussion threads with hundreds of posts covering our products, technology, and various workflow questions. 

If you haven't found what you're looking for, don't hesitate to send us an email


The Basics

Which CineForm product is the right one for you?

CineForm Purchases and Product Activation

My credit card is being rejected in the CineForm online store.  HELP!!
How do I activate my CineForm product?

How do I deactivate my CineForm product?
Can I use CineForm products on multiple machines?

3rd Party Licensing of CineForm Intermediate - Adobe, Sony, etc

Are CineForm Intermediate™ HD components included in Adobe Premiere and Sony Vegas?
Are CineForm Intermediate files compatible between different editing applications?
If Adobe and Sony licensed CineForm Intermediate, why do I need CineForm products?

CineForm Intermediate Codec Related

What is the underlying compression technology used by CineForm Intermediate?
Are CineForm Intermediate files compatible with other applications like After Effects and Combustion?
How big are CineForm Intermediate File Sizes?
When should I use an AVI versus an MOV file wrapper?
Can I rewrap AVI files to MOV files (and vice versa)?
Are 10/12-bit CineForm files compatible with 8-bit applications?
How do I use CineForm files on multiple machines when I only have one license?

Playback of CineForm Intermediate files stutter in Windows.  How can I fix it?

Aspect HD, Connect HD, Neo HDV, and Other HDV Related

Does Aspect HD v5 support both Premiere Pro v2 and CS3?
What features does Aspect HD offer above Adobe's native editing support in Premiere Pro?
Does Aspect HD support Panasonic's HVX-200 camera?
Do CineForm products support special camcorder modes from Canon, JVC, and Sony HDV camcorders?
What is the upgrade policy to Aspect HD v5 and how do I purchase my upgrade?
I don't intend to upgrade to Premiere Pro CS3 right away.  Should I upgrade to Aspect HD v5 anyway?

Exporting CineForm Projects from Premiere Pro as M2T files for Export to HDV Camcorders
     files for export to HDV camcorders....
How do I export to DVD from my Adobe Premiere Pro timeline and maintain best video quality?

Can I batch capture using Neo HD and Aspect HD?

Prospect HD Related

What are the major differences between Prospect HD and Aspect HD?
Does a 10-bit Prospect HD workflow improve visual fidelity on my 8-bit (HDV, DVCPRO HD, HDCam, etc) project?

Does full-raster 1920 horizontal resolution benefit my workflow?
I have uncompressed AVI files.  Can I convert them into CineForm Intermediate?

Do CineForm products support Blackmagic's Decklink cards?
Does Prospect HD work well with animated source material?
Does Prospect HD work with 64-bit Windows XP?
Does Prospect HD support editing of DVCPRO-HD material?

Does Prospect HD support both the HS and LH(e) family of AJA HD-SDI cards?

MacOS Products

Do CineForm files work on MacOS?
Will CineForm release a QuickTime codec for G5 Macs?
How do I get the CineForm QuickTime Codec for Mac?
What Mac applications is the CineForm QuickTime codec compatible with?
Will CineForm files work in real time in Final Cut Pro?
Can I online edit 4K material in Final Cut Pro?
CineForm files don't work within Apple's Color? Why?
How can I rewrap files for cross-platform compatibility?

How do I share content with somebody who hasn't purchased a CineForm product?
Are there cross-platform gamma issues between Windows and MacOS?
How to remove the CineForm QuickTime Codec....

Wafian HR-1 Direct-to-Disk Recorder

Does the HR-1 support timecodes?
Does the HR-1 support RS-422 deck control?

Which component output modes from the HD100U are supported by the HR1?
Will Aspect HD play 10-bit CineForm Intermediate files, or do I need Prospect HD?
Please explain more about the video storage RAID configurations
How do I move data off of the HR-1?
How do I use CineForm Intermediate files on Final Cut Pro or Avid?

I'm mobile.  Can I use battery power for the HR-1?

CineForm RAW Workflow FAQ

What does "demosaic" or "DeBayer" mean?
Explain DeBayering and the CineForm RAW workflow....
On which NLE platforms can I edit CineForm RAW files?
Explain Active Metadata

What cameras are supported by CineForm RAW?

CineForm Support for Red One and RedCine

What is the CineForm workflow that supports the Red camera?
How do I export CineForm files from RedCine?
Will 4K CineForm 444 files work in Premiere Pro and After Effects?
Will 4K CineForm 444 files work in Final Cut Pro?

Other

Do CineForm files work with Avid - or, how do I convert to DNxHD?
Can I convert XDCam HD or XDCam EX files to CineForm Intermediate?
Can I convert JVC TOD files to CineForm Intermediate?
If my source files are AVC or AVC Intra should I still use CineForm Intermediate for post?
How do I convert DPX sequences to CineForm files?
How do I convert CineForm files to DPX files?


The Basics

Q: Which CineForm post-production product is the right one for you?

A: If you are using:


CineForm Purchases and Product Activation

Q: My credit card is being rejected in the CineForm online store.  HELP!!

A: Sometimes credit cards (usually non-US cards) are rejected by the credit card clearinghouse used by our online store, even if the credit card is not over its limit.  Sometimes this is for simple reasons like mistakes when entering the proper billing name, address, or security code.  Other times a rejection can be for "unknown" reasons triggered by anti-fraud algorithms employed by the host bank.  In any event, this is frustrating for everybody.  You have a couple options:

  1. Try a different credit card

  2. We accept Paypal - you might try this payment option.

  3. Contact us by email and explain the problem.  Sometimes we can help by manually entering the order.

Q: How do I activate my CineForm product?

A1:  For CineForm Windows products, visit our activation page www.cineform.com/register.html.  Instructions are also in the PDF user manual after product installation.

A2: For CineForm Mac products, launch the Authenticator application located in the /Applications/CineForm folder on your Mac. Click the "Request License" tab and follow the instructions.

Still have problems or questions with activation? Visit our tech support site and search on "activation", or else email support@cineform.com.

Q: How do I deactivate my CineForm product?

A:  Visit http://www.cineform.com/register.html for deactivation instructions.

Q: Can I use CineForm products on multiple machines?

A1: Yes! When using Windows, you can install your CineForm product(s) (Prospect HD, Aspect HD, Connect HD) on as many machines as you like, although only one activated machine is permitted per serial number at one time.  But if you have a workflow environment where you need to move around your activation to different machines you can easily and automatically do this using the deactivation function within our Activate.exe utility.  To see how this works, run

Start à All Programs à CineForm à Aspect HD* à Activate.exe
        (*or Prospect HD or Connect HD)

If you need to edit on a second machine or a laptop, you can deactivate your primary machine by running the Activate.exe utility and selecting the deactivation operation. Once deactivated, you can immediately activate a different machine by visiting www.cineform.com/register.html and filling in the requested information.  Make sure you have your serial number handy when activating the second machine. 

  • Your System Code will be different on each of your machines, and your activation code received by email will also be different for each machine. 

  • Your CineForm decoder will always remain active on each machine (even after deactivation) so you will always be able to play your material regardless of whether your machine is activated.

  • The deactivation utility is only available on CineForm products beginning in July 2006.  If you have an earlier version you will need to upgrade to a current version or else contact support@cineform.com for deactivation instructions.

NOTE: If you don't need to render into CineForm files on the second machine, you can use CineForm's free Neo Player.  Neo Player installs a non-expiring CineForm decoder plus the After Effects importer. 

A2: When using Mac, we don't have the ability to deactivate one Mac for moving the license to another machine.  If you are moving from one machine to another contact CineForm technical support support@cineform.com for assistance in moving your license.


Industry Licensing Questions - Adobe, Sony, etc

Q: Are CineForm Intermediate™ HD components included in Adobe Premiere and Sony Vegas?

A:  Yes.  Adobe and Sony both licensed certain CineForm Intermediate™ software components from CineForm.  These components originally formed the heart of HDV editing with Premiere Pro (v1.5.1) and Vegas 6.  CineForm continues to work closely with both Adobe and Sony for optimized workflows with their newer products (Adobe CS3 and Vegas 7).

Q: Are CineForm Intermediate files compatible between different editing applications?

A: Yes absolutely.  CineForm will always make sure this is the case.  Supporting both AVI and MOV files (and a re-wrapping feature through HDLink, enhances cross-applications and cross-platform compatibility.

Q: If Adobe and Sony licensed CineForm Intermediate, why do I need CineForm products?

A:  Neither Adobe nor Sony licensed all of CineForm's technologies - they only licensed basic versions of our CineForm Intermediate HDV codec technologies.  Products offered by CineForm include many additional modules built on top of CineForm Intermediate, including 10/12-bit precision, real-time editing pipelines, special capture/conversion modules, deinterlacers, inverse telecine processing, improved chroma interpolation, After Effects importers/exporters, and much more.  Our business is optimizing HD workflows.  Our CineForm Intermediate codec is the base technology upon which we build efficient post-production tools.

But let's get a little more specific. In the case of Premiere Pro, CineForm's Aspect HD literally quadruples (on some machines) the HDV timeline editing performance compared to Premiere Pro's native HDV editing performance.  This is accomplished through our RT video pipeline.  A complete list of impressive performance and workflow features included in Aspect HD that are unavailable in Premiere Pro are described on the Aspect HD product page.

Similar with Sony Vegas, CineForm's Connect HD offers many performance and workflow enhancements to users of Vegas 6.0 and 7.0 that are unavailable through the components we licensed to Sony.  Please view the Neo HD product page for a complete list of additional performance and feature enhancements.


CineForm Intermediate Codec Related

Q: What is the underlying compression technology used by CineForm Intermediate?

A: The CineForm Intermediate codec is based on a temporal Wavelet structure designed by CineForm for the rigorous visual quality demands required in a multi-generation post-production workflow.  We also designed it for very efficient CPU implementation on PC architectures.  The latter is why we have such very high performance - multiple real-time streams - while editing.

The word "temporal" means there is compression among successive frames, but MUCH more efficient than MPEG's notorious interframe coding based on motion estimation (we don't use motion estimation).  Our temporal coding is so efficient that our codec is "symmetric", meaning that encoding and decoding take virtually the same amount of time.  It's also why our render times are so fast.

Another interesting fact is that CineForm Intermediate is "blockless".  What this means is that the image is compressed in one large "chunk". Although its blockless implementation is more complex, the simple reason we do this is for improved image quality.  As most are aware, MPEG (and related algorithms) divide the image into small 8x8 block sizes, each of which is compressed individually and then reassembled upon decoding.  In complex image sequences coded with MPEG you often end up with block noise and edge ringing contributed to by the small block sizes.  This never happens with blockless Wavelet transforms.

Finally, our files are variable bit rate files for improved visual quality, not fixed bitrate.  HDV is necessarily a fixed bitrate system because of the constant bitrate demands of tape recording.  CineForm Intermediate compression allow bitrates to naturally rise in response to visually demanding scenes and fall during less demanding scenes. 

Q: Are CineForm Intermediate files compatible with other applications like After Effects and Combustion?

A: Yes absolutely.  CineForm files have a user-selectable AVI or MOV wrapper around them.  All CineForm products ship with importers/exporters for AE to ensure 10/12-bit compatibility.  For deep precision support within Combustion on Windows you need to use CineForm's MOV wrapper because MOV has more widely used deep-pixel formats than does AVI.  As long as the CineForm codec is installed on PC applications that support Video for Windows or DirectShow, CineForm files should be fully compatible.

Q: How big are CineForm Intermediate File Sizes?

A: CineForm Intermediate files are encoded using a variable bitrate technique, so file sizes vary based on scene complexity, image resolution, frame rate, and chosen compression quality.  But the following ranges apply reasonably well:

HDV: For 1440 x 1080 60i HDV material, you can expect a range of arount 10 - 14 MBytes/sec, or around 40GB/hour.  In comparison, 1280 x 720 24p material will be about half that size.  These files are larger than are generated by in-camera MPEG codecs so as to enable more "headroom" for manipulating the files in post, offering significantly improved visual fidelity within multi-generation workflows.

HD: 1920 x 1080 10-bit 24p streams usually range from about 15MB/sec to 20MB/sec, or about 60GB/hour.

2K: 2K file sizes are comparably larger than HD files because of increased spatial resolution.  Also, if your 2K files originated as film scans they will have a lot of grain in them.  It is for this reason CineForm created our two "Filmscan" modes - to preserve the grain structure from film scan sources. 2K file sizes range typically from about 20MB up to 30MB/sec.  We've seen complex material such as from the StEM (Standardized Evaluation Material) range upwards to 50MB/sec.

CineForm 444: CineForm 444 files are about twice the size (at a given spatial resolution) compared to the equivalent YUV 4:2:2 files at the same spatial resolution.  So 1920x 1080 CineForm 444 files will be about 40 MB/sec.

Q: When should I use an AVI versus an MOV file wrapper?

A: Beginning with Prospect HD v3, Aspect HD v5, and Neo v3, all CineForm products allow recording (capturing) into either AVI or MOV files.  As a general rule if you are using a Windows workflow you'll want to capture into CineForm AVI files and for a MacOS workflow you'll want to use the MOV wrapper. 

There are some exceptions.  For instance, if you are using Combustion on Windows and want to process 10-bit CineForm files you'll need to use CineForm MOV files.  Combustion will not recognize CineForm AVI files as having 10/12 bits of depth.

Q: Can I rewrap AVI files to MOV files (and vice versa)?

A: Yes. Using CineForm's HDLink software you can rewrap from AVI to MOV (and vice versa) without disturbing the underlying compression.  This facilitates moving files from Windows to MacOS and vice-versa.  Using the Convert tab within HDLink, simply select the AVI or MOV source file(s), then select the "other" wrapper as the output format, and if you don't have any other temporal or spatial processing specified, the file will be rewrapped.  If you do specify temporal or spatial processing the the file will be transcoded using the new temporal/spatial parameters you selected.

Q: Are 10/12-bit CineForm files compatible with 8-bit applications?

A: Windows default provides 8-bit compatibility for AVI files between different applications.  But Windows doesn't define a specific interoperable format for 10-bit files that is widely supported in the industry.  So if you're a Prospect HD or Neo HD customer using our 10-bit workflow, we've provided Importers and Exporters for Premiere Pro and After Effects to allow interchangeability with 10-bit CineForm Intermediate files.  If you are using a non-Adobe application, your 10-bit CineForm files will generally be recognized as 8-bit files. 

An exception to this is Windows applications that support deeper (10/12-bit) precision for MOV files.  Combustion is an example of this.  CineForm MOV files on Windows can be read by Combustion with their deeper precision.

Q: How do I use CineForm files on multiple machines when I only have one license?

A1: You can have CineForm products installed on multiple machines simultaneously, but you may only have one machine activated at a time.  This technique is described in more detail here.

A2: CineForm's Neo Player is an installable utility that includes a non-expiring CineForm decoder.  Neo Player supports all CineForm formats including active metadata in CineForm RAW.  Neo Player also includes an After Effects importer so AE can read CineForm files at full bit depth.  Neo Player is helpful if:

(1) You need to share CineForm content with colleagues who do not have a paid CineForm license.  Simply instruct them to download and install Neo Player, or

(2) You have render nodes that need to render out of CineForm files to another format. 

NOTE: The "Player" part of Neo Player is a bit of a red herring right now as we do not include a CineForm "player" as part of the download (this may change in the future).  But Neo Player is fully compatible with Windows Media Player, QT Player, etc.

Q: Playback of CineForm Intermediate files stutter in Windows Media Player.  Can I fix that?

A: Yes.  Remember, HD files in general require more CPU power than SD files.  But the scalability of CineForm's wavelet-based files exceeds other algorithms, so we include a utility to take advantage of this for accelerated playback on slower machines.  This utility allows you to choose playback resolution as either i) full resolution (default) or 2) half-horizontal and half-vertical resolution (which requires less CPU power). 

To enable half-resolution playback select the "Desktop Playback - Fast" option in the CineForm --> Tools directory under Start Menu.  Until you change this back to "Desktop Playback - Quality" all desktop playback will be at half resolution.


Aspect HD, Connect HD, Neo HDV, and Other HDV Related

Q: Does Aspect HD v5 support both Premiere Pro v2 and CS3?

A: Aspect HD v5 supports both Premiere Pro 2 and Premiere Pro CS3.  If you intend to use Aspect HD with Premiere Pro CS3 you must upgrade to Aspect HD v5.

Q: Does Aspect HD support Panasonic's HVX-200 camera?

A: All CineForm products support P2 media from Panasonic's HVX-200.

Q: Do CineForm products support special camcorder modes from Canon, JVC, and Sony HDV camcorders?

A: Yes, most all special camera modes are supported, including telecine removal (24p extraction from 60i), Sony's CineFrame modes, Canon's "F" modes, and JVC's 60 modes.

Q: What is the upgrade policy to Aspect HD v5 and how do I purchase my upgrade?

  1. All Aspect HD customers: Any customer who purchased a previous version of Aspect HD (v1, v2, v3, or v4) may upgrade to Aspect HD v5 for $99 through July 31, 2007 using our online store .  Beginning August 1 the upgrade price will be $149.  All subsequent update releases for v5.x will be provided at no additional charge.

    During the ordering process, please include your existing Aspect HD serial number in the field labeled "Special Instructions".  This will allow us to automatically validate your previous serial number and send out a new serial number for v5.
     

  2. Aspect HD v4 purchases after February 1, 2007: If you purchased Aspect HD v4 on February 1, 2007 or later, you may claim a free upgrade to Aspect HD v5 as long as you complete the upgrade by July 31, 2007.  Beginning August 1, 2007 your upgrade price will be $149. If you are entitled to a free upgrade click here to begin.

Q: I don't intend to upgrade to Premiere Pro CS3 right away.  Should I upgrade to Aspect HD v5 anyway?

A: Our recommendation is to upgrade to Aspect HD v5 by July 31, 2007 for the following reasons:

  • All future features will be in Aspect HD v5 and beyond, and will not be rolled backwards into the Aspect HD v4x family.  If you upgrade to v5 then all future v5.x features will be provided free of charge.

  • New features in Aspect HD v5 will remain backwards compatible with Premiere Pro 2

  • You save $50 by upgrading by July 31, 2007.

Q: Exporting CineForm Projects from Premiere Pro as M2T files for Export to HDV Camcorders

A: As of November 2007 CineForm (finally) supports export of CineForm projects from the Premiere Pro timeline to M2T files for further export to HDV camcorders.  See the M2T Export Tech Note.

Q: How do I export to DVD from my Adobe Premiere Pro timeline and maintain best video quality?

A: We have published a Tech Note outlining the steps to master a high quality DVD from Premiere Pro 2 using a CineForm workflow: http://www.cineform.com/products/TechNotes/Export2DVD.htm.

Q: Can I batch capture using Neo HD and Aspect HD?

A: HDLink, CineForm's external MPEG I/O utility that ships with both Neo HD and Aspect HD, does not perform batch capture.  HDLink does allow you to seek to a timecode.  HDLink records all material after you hit the RECORD button up to the time you hit the STOP button.

When using Aspect HD, and when performing capture within the Premiere Pro capture interface, batch capture to CineForm Intermediate files is supported.  The timecode information is written into the CineForm Intermediate AVI files.


Prospect HD Related

Q: What are the major differences between Prospect HD and Aspect HD?

A: You’ll find that Prospect HD works almost identically to Aspect HD, including all the same real-time performance.  In general, Prospect HD offers increased arithmetic precision, increased spatial resolution, and support for HD-SDI acquisition and timeline monitoring.  Here are a few of the extra features Prospect HD offers:

  • 10-bit precision for improved visual fidelity during post

  • Full-raster 1920 horizontal resolution, including (optional) frame resampling of HDV or DVCPRO HD sources to standard square-pixel formats of 1280 x 720 or 1920 x 1080 (at 10 bits of course)

  • 32-floating-point processing for precise color correction

  • Deep-color I/O module for After Effects allowing the highest-quality composites.

  • Seamless integration with AJA Xena cards supporting HD-SDI and component HD I/O for Ingest, Export, and timeline monitoring

  • Some cool features we have planned but can’t tell you about yet!

Q: Does a 10-bit Prospect HD workflow improve visual fidelity on my 8-bit (HDV, DVCPRO HD, HDCam, etc) project?

A: Yes! For most 8-bit source material a 10-bit post workflow with Prospect HD will provide improved visual fidelity.  Think of it this way….IIf you need to perform operations like color correction, compositing, effects, titling, etc, and especially if you have material with smooth gradients (i.e., blue sky) you will be manipulating your 8-bit source data – adding, multiplying, etc.  Each time you render the source data precision is truncated back to 8 bits.  The 8-bit truncation operations after rendering introduce “banding” commonly visible in smooth gradients.  Instead, when you manipulate 8-bit source data in post but allow precision to grow to 10 bits, your arithmetic precision increases and your gradients will remain smooth.  This is very clear in the image sequence below.  Notice the obvious banding in the 8-bit uncompressed YUV image after gamma correction.  If you click on the image you'll see a full-resolution (1920 x 1080) version.


 

Q: Does full-raster 1920 horizontal resolution benefit my workflow?  

A: For many – absolutely, for a few reasons: 

  • 1440 x 1080 is not a square pixel aspect ratio, but 1920 x 1080 is.  Many post tools prefer square pixel data, so Prospect HD allows high-quality frame-interpolation from 1440 to 1920 horizontal resolution (at 10 bits of course).

  • If you are mixing material from other cameras (from HD-SDI sources or DPX files for instance) the frame sizes are often 1920 x 1080.  It is preferable to use a project setting compatible with your highest resolution source material.

  • If you are outputting 1080 material over HD-SDI, 1440 horizontal resolution is not a supported HD-SDI format, but 1920 is.  This also answers one of the questions about why we didn’t include HD-SDI support within Aspect HD.  It could be done, but it would require real-time interpolation of the data at the time it is routed over HD-SDI.  It makes more sense to offer this support as part of a true 1920 x 1080 10-bit workflow within Prospect HD.

Q: I have uncompressed AVI files.  Can I convert them into CineForm Intermediate?

A: Yes.  Uncompressed AVI files can be imported into either Premiere Pro or After Effects.  From the Premiere Pro (or AE) timeline they can be rendered into CineForm Intermediate 8-bit or 10-bit files. 

Q: Do CineForm products support Blackmagic's Decklink cards?

A: Yes, but only for ingest when using HDLink.  When editing using Prospect HD, the architecture of Blackmagic Decklink cards is different than the AJA cards, and we haven't yet finished adding Blackmagic editing support.  We hope to add support for HD-SDI timeline monitoring using Decklink cards in the future.

Q: Does Prospect HD work well with animated source material?

A: Yes, Prospect HD works very well with animated source material.  As an example of this, the 3D animated film "Santa's Polar Blast" was originally created with Lightwave.  The first step in post was to batch-convert the 2048 x 1500 10-bit animated TIFFs (each frame was a file) into CineForm Intermediate 10-bit AVI files for the remainder of the post-production effort.  Because animated sources are usually "clean" (no noise) they also compress more.  The 2K CineForm Intermediate files averaged around 16MB/sec. 

NOTE: Since this was originally written CineForm introduced CineForm 444 inside Prospect 2K.  Originated source material that remains in RGB format should consider using CineForm 444.

Q: Does Prospect HD work with 64-bit Windows XP?

A: Yes, but if using an HD-SDI card check 64-bit Windows compatibility with AJA and Blackmagic drivers.

Q: Does Prospect HD support editing of DVCPRO-HD material?

A: Yes!  See our HVX200 support page for discussion about the numerous conversion features that are supported.  

Q: Does Prospect HD support both the HS and LH(e) family of AJA HD-SDI cards?

A: Yes - Prospect HD v3 supports both the Xena-HS and Xena-LH(e) HD-SDI cards from AJA for acquisition and timeline monitoring. 


MacOS Products

Q: Do CineForm files work on MacOS?

A: Yes, but only on Intel Macs.  With the CineForm QuickTime codec for Mac, CineForm files work on MacOS in QuickTime-compatible applications like Apple's Final Cut Pro, Motion, and QuickTime Player, Adobe's CS3, Media 100, etc. 

Q: Will CineForm release a QuickTime codec for G5 Macs?

A: Maybe....  We'd like to, and Mac users would like us to do so.  At this point we have no plans that can be discussed publicly.

Q: How do I get the CineForm QuickTime Codec for Mac?

A: On our downloads page  This is the full version of the CineForm Mac codec, but without the conversion utilities and real-time editing engine provided in Neo or Prospect, both of which run on Windows.  The CineForm decoder as part of Neo Player Mac will never expire.  The CineForm encoder will operate with full functionality for 15 days after which a CineForm logo will appear on rendered content as a watermark.

Q: What Mac applications is the CineForm QuickTime codec compatible with?

A: We've done lots of testing with Adobe CS3, Apple (Final Cut Pro, Motion, QuickTime Player), Media 100, and Pomfort Silverstack.  In general we're compatible with most (Intel) Mac apps that support QuickTime.

Q: Will CineForm files work in real time in Final Cut Pro?

A: Yes and no, but mostly yes!  Sorry if that's confusing, but we scratched our head for a while about this too.  See our Tech Note describing Final Cut Pro sequence settings for optimal editing performance using CineForm files.

Can I online edit 4K material in Final Cut Pro?

A: Typically "4K" means 4096-wide rasters which is wider than supported by Final Cut.  However, FCP will support 4000-wide rasters.  For projects which can afford to crop 96 pixels horizontally, the 4000-wide project setting in Final Cut Pro works great with CineForm files.  To support 4000-wide online workflows within FCP, CineForm's Raw format converters include a crop feature to 4000-wide rasters  The crop includes a window placement feature allowing you to select from a far-left-most through far-right-most window placement (or arbitrary window placement in between) for the 4000-raster extraction.  Rendering from FCP to CineForm 444 files also works well at 4000-wide rasters.

Q: CineForm files don't work within Apple's Color? Why?

A: CineForm files currently do NOT work in Apple's Color application.  Why? Color does NOT support QuickTime codecs.  Instead, Color only allows certain codecs (that have somehow been anointed) to be used.  We are in communication with Apple about this, and hope they solve this problem for us soon.  In the mean time, don't hesitate to send an email to Apple with a strong request for them to fix this problem right away.

Q: How can I rewrap files for cross-platform compatibility?

A: CineForm's HDLink utility contains numerous conversion options, including telecine removal, spatial resampling, deinterlacing, speed change, etc.  In addition, AVI files can be rewrapped to MOV files (and vice versa).  More information is here.  Currently HDLink only works on Windows, but it is compatible with both Bootcamp and Parallels. 

Q: How do I share content with somebody who hasn't purchased a CineForm product?

A: Simple.  Have them download and install Neo Player - we have versions both for Windows and MacOS.  Then send them your CineForm files.  They can even edit CineForm files using Neo Player - you just can't render back to a CineForm file until you purchase.

If you want to re-wrap the CineForm files from MOV <--> AVI, download and install CineForm's Neo product.  When Neo is installed, the HDLink utility will re-wrap MOV to AVI (and vice versa) for flexible cross-platform and cross-applications compatibility.  Re-wrapping does NOT re-encode your content - it simply replaces one wrapper with another.  HDLink only runs on Windows, but it is Parallels compatible.

Q: Are there cross-platform gamma issues between Windows and MacOS?

A: There can be, but we think we've nailed most of them.  QuickTime gamma problems are a well-known and frustrating problem when moving files between Windows and MacOS, or even between applications on MacOS.  In particular, if you create a CineForm file on Windows, rewrap it to MOV, place it on the FCP timeline, then render it back to a CineForm file you *may* see a gamma shift, although in most cases this is now handled properly.  This is because Windows presents gamma at 2.2 and MacOS at 1.8.  To fix this problem if it occurs, apply a levels adjustment (0.82) in Final Cut Pro on top of your rendered CineForm clip.  This generally solves the problem.  Second-generation renders in FCP should not show continued gamma movement. 

Q: How to remove the CineForm QuickTime Codec....

A: If you suspect the CineForm QuickTime Codec (or any QuickTime component) is causing problems, you can move it from the components folder (to the desktop, for example), run the affected applications, and move the codec component back into the QuickTime components folder as needed. To delete it entirely you can move it into the trash.

The CineForm QuickTime Codec is in the folder /Library/QuickTime. Drag the file CFHDDecompressor.component and the CFHDCompressor.component to the desktop or the trash. This is all that you need to do to uninstall the CineForm QuickTime Codec. In some cases you may need to restrat your Mac to eliminate the codec from the active cache.

Also, the CineForm folder in the applications folder contains an application called "Uninstall CineForm Codec". Double-click this application to run the uninstaller. The CineForm QuickTime codec in the QuickTime components folder will be removed and the CineForm folder in the applications folder will be removed. The CineForm folder contains also contains a ReadMe, the end user license agreement (EULA), the Authenticator, and the uninstaller. All four of these files will be deleted and the CineForm folder itself will be removed from the applications folder.


Wafian HR-1 Direct-to-Disk Recorder

Q: Does the HR-1 support timecodes?

A: The HR-1 will read embedded timecodes in the HD-SDI stream and place them in the CineForm Intermediate AVI file.  If no timecode information is embedded in the HD-SDI stream, the HR-1 will auto-generate timecode and embed it in the CineForm Intermediate AVI file.  As an example, if you're capturing from either the JVC GY-HD100U from its component HD output, or from the Canon XL H1 using its HD-SDI output, neither provides embedded timecode.  In this case the HR-1 auto-generates timecodes and inserts them into the CineForm Intermediate AVI file.

Q: Does the HR-1 support RS-422 deck control?

A: We intend to add RS422 deck control in the not-too-distant future, but this feature is not yet supported.

Q: Which component output modes from the HD100U are supported by the HR-1?

A: JVC's HD100U offers numerous progressive frame rates over its component HD output that are not available when recording to HDV tape.  In particular, the HD100U generates 60p, 50p, 48p, 30p, 25p, and 24p.  Obviously if you can take advantage of this you have very flexible frame rates to use for beautiful slow motion effects. 

Except for 60p, all of these modes add pulldown to create a resulting 60p component HD signal.  Obviously the desire is to remove pulldown to recover the original progressive signal.  The trick is that there is no signaling information that indicates which frames are duplicates versus original.  So our "magic" is to devise an algorithm that can accurately and reliably determine on-the-fly which frames are duplicates.  We have finished this work, and can accurately eliminate duplicate frames when looking at a white wall and also with the lens cap on.  This pulldown reversal will make its way into both Prospect HD and the Wafian HR-1 in future releases.

Q: Will Aspect HD play 10-bit CineForm Intermediate files, or do I need Prospect HD?

A: Yes, Aspect HD will play 10-bit CineForm Intermediate files.  There are two restrictions:

  1. 10-bit files are interpreted as 8-bit files in Aspect HD via dithering, and

  2. rendering resolution out of Aspect HD is limited to 1440 horizontal pixels.

Q: Please explain more about the video storage RAID configurations

A: Two different RAID configurations - Raid 0 or RAID 1 - are offered for the Wafian HR-1 selectable at the time of order.  RAID configurations are based on 500GB 7200rpm SATA drives:

  • RAID 0 - "Striped".  RAID 0 in the HR-1 is a four-drive configuration in which the drives are seen by the OS as a single large drive equal (almost) to the cumulative size of the individual drives.  In this case, four 500GB drives organized as RAID 0 appear to the OS as a single 2TB drive (minus striping overhead).  There is no redundancy in this configuration, but you get  about 36 hours of CineForm Intermediate files at 1080p24 10-bit.

  • RAID 10 - "Stripe across Mirrors". This configuration uses four drives, and uses both mirroring (for redundancy) and striping (for increased capacity).  4 500GB drives yields almost 1TB (minus striping overhead) of usable storage, enough for about 18 hours of CineForm Intermediate files at 1080p24 10-bit. 

Q: How do I move data off of the HR-1?

A: The HR-1 has IEEE 1394 (Firewire), USB2, and Gigabit Ethernet ports.  Because the HR-1 is based on a PC running Windows XP you can move data onto and off of the HR-1 in a manner identical to any other PC.

Q: How do I use CineForm Intermediate files on Final Cut Pro or Avid?

A: See below - we answer this question in detail....

Q: I'm mobile.  Can I use battery power for the HR-1?

A: The HR-1 can be powered from a power inverter with a battery source.  It requires about 500W so plan accordingly.  A UPS supply for each of two HR-1's was used in the filming of Spoon, and is discussed in the Spoon blog: http://indiefilmlive.blogspot.com/


CineForm RAW Workflow FAQ

Q: What does "Demosaic" or "DeBayer" mean?

A: First of all, please review the CineForm RAW technology tutorial for more information.

In a three-chip (sensor) camera design, each image sensor records only one color component - either Red, Green, or Blue. With proper prism alignment, any R, G, or B photosite located on one of the sensors has a corresponding photosite on a different sensor representing the same pixels point but for a different color channel. This can be considered a 3D array with a 2D dimension representing each pixel location in a grid, and the third dimension representing the three color planes (R, G, and B) stacked vertically.  This RGB organization (or YUV through transformation) is understood by NLE and compositing applications.

When a single-chip "Bayer"  or CFA ("Color Filter Array") sensor is used, all color channels are recorded onto a single (two-dimensional) sensor.  This is accomplished by using different (R, G, or B) filters on each adjacent photosite location in a grid pattern.  (Remember to read the CineForm RAW tutorial where this comes visually more clear....) Because the Bayer structure has adjacent color elements instead of "stacked" color elements, it needs to be handled in an NLE environment differently than traditional RGB or YUV color spaces. A simple way to think about this is that Bayer-pattern data should be considered a different color space than traditional RGB or YUV.  Data acquired from Bayer or CFA sensors in known as "raw" data, and is often considered a "digital negative".  You will often see both terms used.

For an NLE or compositing app to understand Bayer-pattern data it must be converted into a traditional RGB or YUV format.  This is accomplished using a compute-intensive process known as a "Demosaic" or "DeBayer".  There are many different algorithms that have been developed in recent years to perform this task, and each varies in resulting visual quality, and each varies in the amount of compute load required to perform the DeBayer.  The highest quality of these algorithms are very compute intensive and in many cases (especially 4K) cannot be performed in real time.

Q: Explain DeBayering and the CineForm RAW workflow....

A: At some point in a workflow that uses Bayer or CFA sensors, the DeBayer operation must be performed.  It is up to your knowledge of the post-production tools and their capabilities to determine when to perform the DeBayer operation.

CineForm performs the DeBayer operation in two different ways:

  1. Dynamic DeBayer which allows playback of multiple streams of CineForm RAW files (up to 4K) in real time within a calling application, including within an editing or compositing environment.  In this mode the source file remains CineForm RAW, but the CineForm decoder DeBayers the CineForm RAW data and presents it to the calling application as traditional YUV or RGB . This mode defers the need to perform a rendered DeBayer until later in the post workflow. The CineForm decoder performs the dynamic DeBayer operation automatically on CineForm RAW data.
     

  2. DeBayer during Rendering: At the time a render is performed on a CineForm RAW file, the result is always a traditional YUV (CineForm Intermediate) or RGB (CineForm 444) file. 

CineForm RAW is based on the same underlying Wavelet algorithm architecture as CineForm Intermediate, and is the name CineForm gives to the compression of raw sensor data.  Cineform RAW files (like CineForm Intermediate and CineForm 444) exploit the multi-resolution decoding nature inherent when using Wavelets codecs.  The multi-resolution nature of Wavelet codecs assists in the real-time, multi-stream editing workflow provided by CineForm products. 

CineForm RAW files can be moved onto the timelines of supported NLEs, compositing and effects apps, and even played within Windows Media Player or QuickTime player.  Further, within an NLE or compositing environment, you can inter-mix CineForm RAW, CineForm Intermediate, and CineForm 444 media - even on the same timeline.  The CineForm decoder understands the differences in each of the file formats and converts the data (including dynamic DeBayering) to the YUV or RBG format requested by the calling application.

Q: On which NLE platforms can I edit CineForm RAW files?

A: CineForm RAW files are compatible with all NLE applications that already support CineForm's AVI or QuickTime codecs.  Among others, CineForm RAW has a complete editing workflow on Windows using Premiere Pro/After Effects and on MacOS using Final Cut Pro.  Please visit our Tech Notes pages for more detailed descriptions about editing workflows using CineForm RAW.

Q: Explain Active Metadata

A: Active metadata literally means data that is stored within a compressed CineForm file that specifies an operation to be performed on the decoded bitstream prior to delivering the decoded data to the calling application.  Using the Silicon Imaging SI-2K camera as an example, color information is never "flattened" into the compressed video bitstream.  Instead, CineForm RAW lightly compresses the sensor data directly, then stores camera color information (white balance, color saturation matrix, 3D LUT) as "active metadata".  When you play back a CineForm RAW file, the CineForm decoder decompresses the bitstream, then it explores whether color information is present in the file.  If so, the CineForm decoder can optionally apply the color information to the decoded bitstream prior to passing the output to the calling application. 

This is a valuable technique to preserve highlight detail from the camera's sensor.  You see, in a traditional camera, white balance and color matrix processing is "flattened" into the bitstream.  Such processing can reduce highlight detail significantly depending on the amount of processing.  As long as color information is stored as "active metadata" instead, highlights from the camera's sensor remain in the source bitstream and color processing remains a post process.  Color information can always be changed or eliminated altogether without impacting the original source data.

There will be many other features CineForm adds that make use of active metadata, but we'll keep some of these ideas to ourselves for now....

For more information about how active metadata is used in CineForm RAW files, please read the CineForm RAW Technology Primer.

Q: What cameras are supported by CineForm RAW?

A1: CineForm RAW is the native recording format for the Silicon Imaging SI-2K camera.

A2: CineForm has RAW converters for Red One (not yet shipping), Dalsa Origin, and Vision Research Phantom cameras.  Visit the Tech Note page to learn more about CineForm's RAW Converters for the Dalsa and Vision Research Phantom cameras.


CineForm Support for Red One and RedCine

Q: What is the CineForm workflow that supports the Red camera?

A: You can export directly from RedCine to CineForm MOV files on both Windows and MacOS.  When spatial resolution of HD (1920x1080) or smaller is selected, the CineForm 4:2:2 encoder is automatically selected.  For any selected spatial resolutions above 1920 x 1080, the CineForm 444 encoder is selected.

NOTE 1: Currently CineForm 444 export on the Mac is limited to 2K.  This will change in the near future.

NOTE 2: Some Windows applications prefer AVI files over MOV.  The HD Link utility installed with Neo 4K will replace the MOV wrapper on the exported CineForm 444 MOV files with an AVI wrapper without disturbing the compression underneath.  Because no recompression is involved, the re-wrap process is very fast.

Q: How do I export CineForm files from RedCine?

A: See the following CineForm Tech Note for instructions on exporting CineForm files from RedCine.

Q: Will 4K CineForm 444 files work in Premiere Pro and After Effects?

A: Yes.  We recommend Prospect 4K for Premiere Pro (Windows) workflow.  Either Neo 4K or Prospect 4K work with After Effects or other 4K-capable applications.  See the CineForm Tech Note for using Prospect 4K with Red One source footage

NOTE 1: The large frame sizes may cause problems with Premiere Pro's memory architecture (PPro didn't really contemplate an online 4K workflow) and may cause crashing when rendering at 4K.  We're looking into modifying Premiere Pro's memory architecture to better handle these large frames.

NOTE 2: For Premiere Pro, we recommend setting up a 2K project not a 4K project.  4K CineForm 444 material exported from RedCine plays very well in a 2K Premiere Pro project.  This workflow allows you to maintain 4K source during post, but to use a 2K project as we expect most final outputs will be delivered in 2K RGB.  (This also solves the memory-related crashing problem mentioned in Note 1.

Q: Will 4K CineForm 444 files work in Final Cut Pro?

A: No, but 2K CineForm 444 files work fine, which you can easily export out of RedCine.  Currently the maximum spatial resolution handled by FCP is 2K. 


Other

Q: Do CineForm files work with Avid - or, how do I convert to DNxHD?

A1: Unfortunately Avid supports no third-party compressed codecs regardless of the file wrapper.  If you want to use Avid software with CineForm files you'll need to export them to DPX files or DNxHD files using third-party tools. 

A2: CineForm customers have been successful exporting CineForm files to DNxHD files using After Effects and also using MPEG Streamclip. You need the DNxHD codec installed on your machine which you can get from the Avid website.

Q: Can I convert XDCam HD or XDCam EX files to CineForm Intermediate?

A: Yes, within CineForm's HDLink which ships within our Neo, Aspect HD, and Prospect HD/2K products.  Simply select XDCam HD (.mxf) or XDCam EX (.mp4 or .mxf) files as you would select any file for conversion. 

NOTE: For 4-channel audio, channels 1 & 2 are multiplexed inside the AVI file.  Channels 3 & 4 are contained in s separate .WAV file that you can move onto your timeline.

Q: Can I convert JVC TOD files to CineForm Intermediate?

A: Yes within CineForm's HDLink which ships within our Neo, Aspect HD, and Prospect HD/2K products.  Simply select JVC's TOD files as you would select any file for conversion.

Q: If my source files are AVC or AVC Intra should I still use CineForm Intermediate for post?

A: The quick answer is YES, but let's dive a bit deeper....

Algorithm: First of all, the AVC algorithm is similar to MPEG4, and both derive use DCT processing as does the original MPEG 2 spec that preceded them.  AVC does include 10-bit recording capability for those camera and DDR manufacturers that choose to use extended precision.  "Intra" is simply the I-frame version of the otherwise long-GOP implementation of AVC. As of this writing, newer consumer HD cameras from Sony and Panasonic are using AVC long-GOP recording.  Panasonic has also chosen to use AVC Intra for their Professional cameras and decks. 

Qualitative Quality: At this point it is worth noting that the AVC Intra algorithm chosen by Panasonic has similarities to the MPEG 4 Intra algorithm used by Sony in HDCam SR.  But Panasonic has chosen a bitrate cap on AVC Intra at 100 Mbps, whereas HDCam SR offers two bitrate modes of 440Mbps and 880Mbps.  We haven't yet performed a visual quality analysis of AVC Intra, but we expect that at 100Mbps the visual fidelity of AVC Intra will be noticeably lower than HDCam SR.  In April 2007 CineForm performed a visual quality analysis of CineForm 444 versus HDCam SR. The results of that test show that CineForm compression is superior to that of the respected HDCam SR format.  It follows that given the relatively low bitrate of AVC Intra that CineForm will maintain a significant quality advantage over AVC Intra both for original recording as well as for a multi-generation post workflow.

Post-Production Performance: AVC (and MPEG 4) use an entropy coding algorithm known as "arithmetic coding". (Entropy coding removes redundancy from the bitstream after transform processing, separate from the visual redundancy exposed by the DCT).  Arithmetic coding is more efficient (by about 10% to 20%) in the size of recorded files than "Huffman coding" that was used in earlier JPEG and MPEG 2 algorithms.  The resulting smaller bitstreams are beneficial when recording to tape or flash-based media as you will gain an extra 10% - 20% more material recorded for a given media size. 

But there is a cost to the modest extra efficiency in file size.  Specifically, arithmetic coding is extremely inefficient to encode and decode on CPUs, so the algorithms are quite slow.  In a camera or DDR usually a hardware encoder is used, so CPU inefficiency is never exposed.  But in a post environment with software decoders, the inefficiency of arithmetic coding becomes very visible. 

As many are aware, CineForm compression uses a full-frame Wavelet for compression to avoid block artifacts often present in DCT-based algorithms.  Further, CineForm avoids using arithmetic coding because of its inefficient CPU performance.  The result is that CineForm compression a large performance advantage in addition to its visual quality advantage.  In a post environment CineForm compression will exceed the encode/decode performance of AVC Intra algorithms by 3X-4X.  That means that 3 or 4 CineForm streams can be decoded using the same CPU that is decoding one AVC Intra stream. 

Bottom Line: As a result of higher CineForm visual fidelity and much higher performance in post, CineForm recommends that you convert AVC (Intra) streams into Cineform Intermediate for your post-production workflow.

 

Q: How do I convert DPX sequences to CineForm files?

A: CineForm has a shell-based batch conversion utility that will convert DPX files to CineForm files on Windows.  Read the Tech Note.

Q: How do I convert CineForm files to DPX sequences?

A: CineForm has a shell-based batch conversion utility that will convert CineForm AVI or MOV files to DPX sequences on Windows.  Read the Tech Note.

 

 

Copyright © 2005 CineForm, Inc.  All rights reserved.    |    Privacy Policy